We found a grave marker on the trail, not far from where the trail met the road. "Here lies an unknown man killed by the Kirkland Bushwackers," read the simple granite slab.
The gang referenced in the marker was named for its leader, John Jackson Kirkland. He and most of the other members were deserters during the Civil War. They roamed the mountains of Tennessee and North Carolina to harass, rob, and sometimes kill locals, especially those suspected of being Union sympathizers.
There aren't many details about what led to the death of the unknown man murdered near Mud Gap, but other stories describe the gang's bloodthirsty ruthlessness. One tells of when they were waiting to rob a Union Army payroll officer. A couple with their baby stumbled into the gang's hiding spot. When the baby wouldn't stop crying, it was murdered. One of the gang members stuffed the baby's body in a hollow tree.
When Kirkland died in 1902 at age 75, he had never been arrested or served a warrant for his crimes. According to legend, no law officer wanted to confront him.