Although I never asked, I wondered if maybe OldTimer had decided to take a zero day in Encampment to give Top O' and me a chance to catch up. If so, that was alright with me. I tried to talk No Keys and him into joining us when we were in Chama.
After Top O' and I left Chama to follow the lower route into Colorado, OT and No Keys attempted to cross the high route in the San Juans. They soon realized that way was too dangerous and difficult. No Keys got off the trail, and OT ended up flipping to Wyoming at about the same time we did.
OT hiked several more miles than us in Wyoming. Because he had better luck than we did in getting there, he arrived a day or two before us. He then started walking from a spot farther north than we did.